Friday, May 8, 2015

Pre-K: Tea Party lets Abbott save face after extracting concessions


"And the things that you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit these to faithful men who will be able to teach others also."
2 Timothy 2:2

This website has no idea why Governor Abbott made pre-K his top priority.  Furthermore, we don't understand why legislators have been so willing to go along with this.  That being said, this isn't an entirely unreasonable outcome:

I want to give you an update on the Pre-K bill that none of us wanted (except the Governor). Because it is Abbott's pet...
Posted by Julie White McCarty on Friday, May 8, 2015


While any pre-K program is a step in the wrong direction, if this is what the final product looks like, it won't be the end of the world.

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Kabuki Theater: Did Poncho Nevarez ever install a Panic Button?!?


"He who speaks truth declares righteousness,
But a false witness, deceit."
Proverbs 12:17

At the beginning of the 84th Legislature, there was a controversy regarding Representative Poncho Nevarez and "Panic Buttons."  In late March, this website put an open records request into the Department of Public Safety for all communications with Representative Poncho Nevarez concerning setting up a panic button.  The search turned up bupkus.



According to DPS records, the only communications they've had with Representative Nevarez's office this session was concerning HB 2405, a bill pertaining to signage requirments for businesses that do not permit carry on their premises that was left pending in April.

[Author's Note: Due to formatting issues, we can't embed the e-mails, so we've cut and pasted the text.]
Hey Mr. Bowie!
Thanks so much for getting back to me. I spoke with our legislative director and she said that we basically are just wanting someone from DPS to testify on the bill neutrally or in favor (although we do believe DPS is unable to testify in favor) at the bill hearing, if possible. We would greatly appreciate it! I have attached the bill rational as well as the text. If you have any questions please feel free to call.
Thanks again.
[REDACTED]
Legislative Assistant
Representative Poncho Nevarez
DPS response:
 State agencies are prohibited from taking a position on any legislation. We are happy to provide a resource witness on the bill and answer questions the members may have regarding our operations or anticipated implementation of the provisions of the bill.
Please let me know if you have questions.  Also, in the future, please reach out to me or my staff (Office of Government Relations) should you need anything in the future from the department.
   Thank you.
   [REDACTED]
   Deputy Assistant Director
   Office of Government Relations
   Texas Department of Public Safety
Nevarez's office writes back:
Thanks so much! We would appreciate it if you could provide a resource witness for HB 2405 as soon as possible!
[REDACTED]
Legislative Assistant 
Representative Poncho Nevarez
Bottom Line: If Poncho Nevarez had installed a panic button, one would think DPS would have a record of the communication.

Wednesday, May 6, 2015

TPPF: Freedom of Association vs. Forced Disclosure


"So then, my beloved brethren, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath;"
James 1:19

Texas Public Policy Foundation -- Last night, TPPF hosted an event discussing the perils of donor intimidation vs. "disclosure."  Participants were Paul Avelar of the Institute for Justice and Vice Chairman Chase Untermeyer of the Texas Ethics Commission.  Mr. Untermeyer's words speak for themselves.

Untermeyer opening remarks:



Highlights:
  • Asked Joe Straus to put him on the "Ethics" Commission.
  • "The status quo is usually the right course."
  • "Ethics" Commission only has civil jurisdiction.
  • Empower Texans case wasn't about disclosure.
  • Attacks against donors aren't retaliation, they're "politics."



Highlights:
  • Anonymity is inherently suspect?!?
  • Transparency leads to trust.
  • We vote in private for a reason.
  • "Dark money" goes to a non-profit.



Highlights:
  • Discussing Texas-specific topics could make him a lobbyist.
  • Non-profits can inform voters of politicians records.
  • "Not liking what is being said is not reason to restrict speech."
  • It's not the government's business.
  • Sometimes, unpopular speech needs to be anonymous.
  • The best judge of speech is the speech itself.
  • These types of political reprisals are well documented.



Highlights:
  • Untermeyer scared of the term "Dark Money."
  • The public does not have an interest in knowing who pays for a non-profit campaign that the government can enforce.
    • It's the organization's choice.
  • "The speaker controls the message in America."



Highlights:
  • Belittles Avelar's examples.
  • Empower Texans has more influence than NAACP in Alabama.
  • TPPF doesn't get involved in elections, so who cares?!?



Highlights:
  • Most people believe in "privacy for me but not for thee."
  • Non-profits can't have their main function be influencing elections.
  • "Undue influence" standard "is dangerous."
    • Legal morass
Untermeyer summation:



Highlights:
  • "There is no public harm in disclosure."
    • Author's Note: Talk about Chutzpah



Highlights:
  • ISIS attack in Garland proves how far people are willing to go to shut down speech.
  • Americans are no more influenced by political ads than from commercial ads.
    • You still need a good product underneath.
    • cf. New Coke
Q&A:





Highlights:

  • Disclosure laws have the greatest effect on small donors with regular lives.
  • Political branches are full of incumbents.
  • Untermeyer dodges Tony McDonald's question.
  • Mozilla CEO was discovered by California disclosure laws.
    • Untermeyer didn't care
  • Internet has made donor intimidation much easier.
    • There are groups that mine this data.
  • Untermeryer: Donors to big, established organizations have more rights.
  • You can evaluate speech on it's own merits.

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

History Lesson: Transparency in Mr. McRaven's world


"Can anyone hide himself in secret places,
So I shall not see him?” says the Lord;
“Do I not fill heaven and earth?” says the Lord."
Jeremiah 23:24

With open records back in the news at U.T., it's worth remembering how Mr. McRaven handled public inquiries in his last job:



Plano Pastor communicates with congregation; political opponents throw a tantrum


"The sinners in Zion are afraid;
Fearfulness has seized the hypocrites:
'Who among us shall dwell with the devouring fire?
Who among us shall dwell with everlasting burnings?' "
Isaiah 33:14

Last December, the city of Plano enacted a "transgender" bathroom ordinance against the will of the people.  The first round of local elections since then takes place this Saturday.  Unfortunately, a local pastor reminded his congregation of this fact and we can't have community leaders communicating about public events using available means:



[Author's Note: While the story claims Church members objected to the e-mail, we find it revealing that they didn't interview any Church members for the story.]

From the Story:
Two weeks ago, the executive pastor of Prestonwood Baptist Church sent an e-mail from his personal account. In it, Pastor Mike Buster endorsed five candidates in next week's local elections.
Some church members are concerned that this message crossed the line.
Matt Lagos is not a church member, but he is a candidate — one who is not mentioned in the pastor's e-mail.
"We need to keep the church separate from politics," Lagos said.
Lagos is challenging Ronald Kelley, who is mentioned in the e-mail for the Place 5 Plano City Council seat.
Referring to Kelley, Pastor Buster writes in the e-mail:
"We need to make sure we are electing local leaders who support our Christian values and who stand for the people."
Kelley is with Prestonwoood's ministerial staff and is director of the Prestonwood Foundation. 
In other words, a Pastor was communicating about a local election with friends as a private citizen and the people who didn't like what he had to say are now trying to create a Federal case where none exists.

On the other hand, this case could provide an excellent opportunity to finally litigate the Johnson Amendment.

First Amendment Tuesday: Week 16


"and for me, that utterance may be given to me, that I may open my mouth boldly to make known the mystery of the gospel,"
Ephesians 6:19

Fun times this morning.

Jim Graham (Texas Right to Life) (Partial):



Highlights:
  • Just because we made concessions 15 years ago doesn't mean we'd make them today.
  • SB 575 by Taylor on Senate floor today.
    • Author's Note: This video was recorded around 9AM, the bill passed around noon.
  • Bills have to be done by May 14th.



Highlights:
  • Byron Cook playing much bigger shenanigans with witness registration than Stickland ever did.
  • Troy Fraser left during American Laws for American Courts hearing.
  • Judy Zaffirini gave Donna Campbell the pre-K bill to give it a "conservative" face.
  • Don Huffines: "At what point do you want children to go into pre-K?!?"
    • Proved liberals want to do this at birth.



Highlights:
  • Pastor Protection bill moving surprisingly quickly.
    • "There will be no more changes to this bill."
    • ACLU amendment language would have added another layer of bureaucratic B.S.
  • "This bill is not about consensus."
  • Senate could move on SB 2065 this week.
  • No movement on bill to smackdown local "Non-discrimination" ordinances.
Texas Homeschool Coalition:



Highlights:
  • College admission bill has been voted out of Senate.
  • Tebow bill passed Senate Ed committee two weeks ago with bi-partisan support.
  • Parental rights bill has the most hurdles to climb.
  • Sticklan has bill to allow foster parents to homeschool.



Highlights:

  • ALAC only pertains to divorce and child custody.

Stickland addresses Accusations


"And you shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."
John 8:32

Jonathan Stickland released a statement yesterday about last week's nonsense:
I want to address an unfortunate incident that took place last Thursday evening. I was set to lay out HB 142, which would eliminate red light cameras, in front of the Transportation Committee. Because our floor activity went so long that day, my layout was delayed until well into the evening. Many supporters of the bill had waited all day – some for twelve hours – to testify and were still waiting. Thank you all for coming out to support the bill.

Earlier in the day on Thursday, I objected to a bill carried by the Democrat Chairman of Transportation on the local and consent calendar, which would have given powers of arrest, search, and seizure to Federal Reserve security guards. Because of that confrontation, I approached Chairman Pickett of El Paso before his committee reconvened to make sure that my bill was still set for a hearing. I was informed that it was, and there was no discussion with me of any concerns on his part about the bill or the witness registration process.

Unfortunately, when I went to lay out my bill, I was prevented from doing so in a very deliberate and dramatic way. It was what I can only characterize as an ambush by a political opponent. Pickett hurled accusations at me and then refused to hear the bill, cutting off all of the members of the public from testifying on the legislation.

Let me make something clear. At that time, I had no idea what Mr. Pickett was referring to, and still have no firsthand knowledge of the facts related to his accusations.

Tensions run high at this point of the session, and I am not surprised that Mr. Pickett would be upset with me for knocking his bill off of the local and consent calendar. However, there is no reason that he could not have discussed his concerns with me in advance of the hearing. I would have gladly worked with him to resolve them.

As best as I can tell, the accusation Chairman Pickett leveled is that some people were registered in support of my bill who were not present in the Capitol building. My attorneys and I have reviewed the laws, the rules, the witness affirmation forms, and the House personnel manual and have been unable to locate anything that commands that a person must be present in the capitol to register their support or opposition to a bill. In fact there are rules which suggest exactly the opposite.

....

Thank you all for your support and prayers. In my last campaign, I told all of you that I am not down here to make friends but to defend life, liberty, and fight for limited government. My voting record and actions prove that I have made good on that promise. It is an honor to serve you.
Read the whole thing here.